Skip to content

Please note

Reading this site, or contacting me through it, does not create a therapist and client relationship. Nothing here is clinical advice for your situation.

PSYCHOLYTIC PERSPECTIVES • ARTICLE 07

When Adaptation Becomes a Measure of Health

The pathology of normal


Our capacity to adapt to seemingly unfathomable conditions is not only extraordinary, but essential to our survival. Yet this same capacity may become one of our greatest vulnerabilities when we collectively mistake adaptation for health.

BY ALAN ROMANO, LCSW · Psycholytic Services LLC | Vero Beach, Florida

The Extraordinary Human Capacity to Normalize

Human beings possess an extraordinary capacity to adapt. We survive changing environments, endure adversity, navigate relationships, and develop ways of organizing ourselves within the world. Yet we adapt not only to physical conditions, but also to the beliefs, expectations, and institutions that define what seems ordinary.

Circumstances once considered unimaginable can become familiar through repetition and cultural reinforcement. What one generation experiences as extraordinary may become unquestioned by the next. Shared systems of meaning establish not only what people value, but what they believe they must sacrifice or endure.

The central question, then, is not whether we can adapt. It is how we distinguish conditions that support human well-being from conditions that have merely become difficult to question.

Cover art for Psycholytic Perspectives 07, The Pathology of Normal: a man with closed eyes behind a cracked mask, between a Maya pyramid with ceremonial figures at sunset and a crowd before a columned building and city towers
Plate 1. Psycholytic Perspectives 07.

When Suffering Becomes Sacred

At the ancient Maya city of Chichén Itzá, ritual sacrifice belonged to a complex ceremonial tradition concerned with sacred forces, mortality, and cosmic order. A 2024 genetic study of children recovered from a ritual burial identified closely related individuals, including two pairs of identical twins, providing new insight into Maya ceremonial life (Barquera et al., 2024).

The Maya ballgame likewise carried religious and political significance beyond athletic competition. Imagery connected the game with life, death, and sacrifice, although the familiar claim that losing teams were routinely sacrificed is not established as a universal practice (Earley, 2017). These examples should not reduce a civilization distinguished by achievements in mathematics, astronomy, agriculture, and architecture to its ritual practices. They illustrate instead how collective understanding of existence can make profound suffering intelligible within a particular moral and spiritual order.

Other traditions connect physical ordeal to social transition. On Pentecost Island in Vanuatu, Naghol land diving involves leaping from wooden towers with vines secured around the ankles. The practice is connected to agricultural and communal traditions, while its contemporary presentation also reflects tensions between cultural continuity and tourism (Cheer et al., 2013). Among the Sateré-Mawé of the Brazilian Amazon, male initiation may involve woven gloves containing bullet ants, whose painful stings form part of a recognized ceremonial ordeal (Carvalho, 2015; Magnani, 2010).

Arnold van Gennep (1960) described rites of passage through separation, transition, and incorporation. Victor Turner (1969) further developed the concept of liminality, the condition of standing between established social identities. Their work helps explain how difficult experiences can acquire meaning through recognized transitions into new responsibilities.

Understanding cultural meaning, however, is not the same as establishing that a practice is physically safe or psychologically beneficial. The larger question is how shared belief influences what people regard as necessary, acceptable, or sacred. A tradition can carry profound significance for its participants while still inviting inquiry into the relationship between endurance, agency, and well-being. The point is not to impose a single contemporary judgment across distinct cultures, but to recognize that the meaning assigned to suffering and its consequences are different questions.

Pain, Transcendence, and Transformation

Religious and contemplative traditions have also interpreted physical hardship as devotion, sacrifice, or spiritual transformation. Fasting, piercing, prolonged exertion, and austerity may be undertaken within ceremonial contexts that give those experiences meanings distinct from pain alone.

Forms of the Sun Dance among several Indigenous nations of the North American Great Plains have included fasting, prayer, dancing, and, in certain traditions, ceremonial piercing. These practices differ across nations and should be understood within their own spiritual and communal contexts, not as a single interchangeable ritual (Stover, n.d.).

One striking historical account concerns the Mandan Okipa ceremony, observed by George Catlin in 1832. Catlin described a four-day ceremony involving fasting, prayer, and communal participation. Some male participants, he reported, had wooden splints inserted through pierced tissue in their chests or shoulders and were suspended by cords attached to the splints, sometimes until they lost consciousness (Catlin, 1841). His description conveys the physical intensity of the ordeal, but it is also the account of an outside nineteenth-century observer and must not be mistaken for a complete Indigenous interpretation of the ceremony.

Within Hindu traditions, some Thaipusam devotees undertake demanding processions, carry kavadis, or participate in bodily piercing as expressions of devotion. Research has examined how religious context and expectation relate to the experience of pain during such ceremonies (Jegindø et al., 2013). The diverse history of yoga likewise includes ascetic discipline, meditation, breath regulation, and tapas, a concept associated with disciplined effort and austerity, although yoga cannot be reduced to deliberate suffering (Mallinson, 2020; Singleton, 2010).

Research on extreme collective rituals has identified associations between demanding participation and prosocial behavior, but these findings do not show that suffering reliably creates psychological healing or lasting transformation (Xygalatas et al., 2013).

An experience may be profound in its intensity and significance without necessarily producing lasting transformation. It may alter awareness, deepen connection, or produce insight without changing the conditions through which someone lives. Transformation cannot be measured by the intensity of an experience alone, but by what becomes possible afterward. This becomes especially important in clinical settings, where an intense emotional release, a striking insight, or an altered state may be interpreted as a turning point. Such experiences deserve attention, but their lasting value must be considered in the context of everyday functioning, relationships, and choices.

Perhaps the greatest danger of our capacity to adapt is not what we learn to endure, but what we can gradually learn to accept as justified.

When the Unthinkable Becomes Institutionalized

Examining the meaning of suffering within cultural traditions is fundamentally different from examining the deliberate organization of persecution by a political state. These phenomena are neither morally nor historically equivalent. Their relevance to the question of normality lies in how established beliefs and authority can shape what people perceive as legitimate.

Nazi Germany demonstrates the catastrophic consequences of institutionalized persecution. The Holocaust was not simply the result of people becoming accustomed to cruelty. It emerged through longstanding antisemitism, racial ideology, propaganda, discriminatory laws, coercion, war, and deliberate decisions by state authorities and participants. The Nazi regime progressively stripped Jews of rights, livelihoods, and legal protection before carrying out genocide (United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, n.d.).

Government offices, courts, schools, professional organizations, and administrative systems helped implement or reinforce persecution. Through these structures, exclusion could be presented as lawful duty or national necessity. Institutions ordinarily associated with order and legitimacy became instruments of profound injustice (United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, 2023).

Responses were not uniform. Some people participated enthusiastically, others accommodated or benefited from persecution, and others resisted or assisted victims at personal risk. Institutional pressure influenced behavior without erasing moral agency. The Holocaust must remain understood in its historical specificity, including the antisemitic ideology and intentional violence that made it possible.

An FSRT perspective: When Adaptation Reinforces Dysfunction

A System’s capacity to maintain itself does not establish that it is healthy.

Within Functional Systems Regulation Theory (FSRT), adaptation may preserve a harmful pattern without validating it. An institution can continue functioning efficiently while the practices it maintains violate the purposes it claims to serve. The danger of normalization therefore extends beyond what people endure to what they may rationalize, accommodate, or participate in when authority presents it as ordinary. This perspective does not explain intentional wrongdoing or distribute responsibility equally among participants. Rather, it highlights the importance of maintaining ethical scrutiny precisely when a policy has become routine, professionally endorsed, or administratively efficient.

When Initiation Becomes Indoctrination

The influence of collective expectations also appears in everyday organizations, particularly where membership promises identity, recognition, and belonging. Rites of passage have historically marked changes in responsibility and social status (van Gennep, 1960; Turner, 1969). Contemporary transitions into adulthood may instead involve informal tests of loyalty whose developmental value is far less clear.

Fraternity hazing and coercive alcohol consumption offer familiar examples. Research across American college organizations has documented forced drinking, humiliation, isolation, and sleep deprivation. Students sometimes report experiencing such behaviors without identifying them as hazing, suggesting how practices can become normalized within group expectations (Allan & Madden, 2008).

The rationale is often that shared hardship creates solidarity. Yet a longitudinal study of fraternity inductees found little support for the claim that more severe hazing reliably strengthened group cohesion (Cimino & Thomas, 2022). Related research associated more severe hazing with attrition, especially among those initially less committed to membership (Cimino et al., 2024). These findings do not establish universal effects, but they complicate the assumption that enduring harm is necessary for belonging.

A meaningful initiation may challenge someone while expanding autonomy and responsibility. Indoctrination instead makes acceptance conditional upon compliance and discourages independent judgment. The concern is not that every demanding experience is harmful. It is that someone may emerge feeling accepted while also having learned to disregard discomfort, boundaries, or personal values to preserve that acceptance.

There is a meaningful difference between a group that challenges its members to grow and one that requires them to demonstrate loyalty by surrendering judgment. The former can cultivate confidence and responsibility; the latter may reward the very habits of submission that undermine autonomy. Such lessons can extend beyond a particular organization. When accommodation is repeatedly rewarded and disagreement threatens connection, suppressing one's needs can become a familiar relational strategy. Yet these patterns often begin long before adulthood, in the earliest relationships through which people learn what safety and belonging require.

When Adaptation Becomes Identity

From childhood onward, people learn which emotions are welcomed, which behaviors receive approval, and what seems necessary to maintain connection. Repeated experiences can influence emotional processing, expectations of others, and later relationships, although developmental outcomes vary and are never inevitable (Bourne et al., 2022; Wade et al., 2022).

Consider a child raised amid unpredictable reactions. Anticipating another person's mood may become a useful protective skill. The child learns to monitor facial expressions, shifts in tone, and subtle indications of conflict. In adulthood, the same vigilance may persist even in relationships that no longer require it. The person may describe themselves as naturally anxious, overly sensitive, or responsible for everyone's emotions, without recognizing the circumstances in which those responses developed.

Similar adaptations can arise in environments that reward achievement, emotional suppression, or self-sacrifice. Someone who receives recognition chiefly through performance may equate worth with productivity. Someone whose early relationships demanded accommodation may understand ignoring personal needs as evidence of love.

Our understanding of love is not formed solely by what love is, but by how we first experienced being loved. When neglect, instability, or suffering become intertwined with those earliest experiences, we may unconsciously mistake what feels familiar for what it means to be loved.

Familiarity and safety are not synonymous. A relationship may feel recognizable because it reproduces intermittent affection, emotional withdrawal, or the need to earn approval. Conversely, consistent care may initially feel unfamiliar. This does not mean people consciously seek suffering, nor that early adversity determines adult relationships. It means that our earliest experiences can shape what we expect intimacy to feel like. A person may be drawn to the emotional intensity of uncertainty because uncertainty is recognizable, while experiencing calm, dependable affection as strangely unfamiliar. The work of change may therefore require learning not only to identify unsafe dynamics but also to remain present within relationships that do not reproduce earlier patterns.

FSRT describes the persistence of such established responses as homeostatic patterning. A strategy developed to preserve safety, or connection may continue organizing perception, emotion, and behavior after the original conditions have changed. Its familiarity contributes to continuity, even when the effort required to maintain it becomes costly.

These adaptations can be highly effective. Sensitivity to other people may support empathy; achievement-oriented habits may lead to professional success; emotional restraint may help someone navigate a crisis. Their usefulness in one context does not establish that they should organize every context. Those costs are not always visible. A person may appear capable, responsible, and composed while devoting considerable energy to monitoring threats, suppressing emotions, or anticipating disapproval. Research on allostatic load offers a related physiological perspective on the cumulative consequences of repeated stress-system activation (McEwen, 1998). FSRT uses regulatory burden to consider the broader psychological and relational demands of maintaining established patterns.

An FSRT perspective: From Survival to Reorganization

What becomes familiar to a system is not necessarily what allows it to thrive.

FSRT describes this process as Homeostatic Patterning, the tendency of a system to organize and maintain familiar patterns of functioning, even when those patterns perpetuate distress or limit growth. Recognizing the origins of these adaptations does not reduce personality to trauma or dismiss the influence of temperament, biology, choice, and later experience. Rather, it invites a different clinical question: not simply whether someone is functioning, but what that functioning requires of them and whether the conditions sustaining it continue to support their well-being.

When Treatment Creates the Illusion of Growth and Reinforces Trauma

The distinction between adaptation and health becomes especially consequential within institutions intended to treat psychological suffering. If families and social systems can reinforce harmful patterns, treatment systems must also be willing to examine whether their practices sometimes do the same.

In my clinical work with mental health and substance use disorders, I have encountered people who describe ten, twenty, or even thirty treatment episodes. Their experiences raise questions about continuity of care, the circumstances to which they return, and whether each episode addresses the patterns contributing to recurrent distress. A treatment episode may interrupt a crisis without resolving the housing instability, unsafe relationships, financial insecurity, or entrenched protective strategies that await a person after discharge. The distinction matters because successful completion of a program and sustainable recovery are not identical outcomes.

National treatment data underscore the prevalence of prior treatment histories. Among 2023 admissions with documented treatment history, nearly seven in ten involved a person who had previously received treatment, and approximately one in five involved five or more prior episodes (Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration [SAMHSA], 2025). These are admissions, not unique individuals; they do not establish that earlier care failed or caused harm. Recovery is rarely linear, and recurring treatment needs may reflect co-occurring conditions, environmental instability, limited resources, or the chronic nature of some disorders.

Continuity after discharge is another concern. Research has examined readmissions and gaps in follow-up care after inpatient or detoxification services, highlighting the importance of what happens beyond the treatment episode itself (Reif et al., 2017). Studies of treatment processes similarly emphasize that quality cannot be assessed solely by what occurs within a facility (Harris et al., 2015).

The problem is not structure itself. Intensive care, medication, behavioral expectations, and therapeutic boundaries can be essential and lifesaving. But an organization may describe itself as trauma-informed while relying on confrontation, humiliation, punitive consequences, or withdrawal of privileges to secure compliance. SAMHSA's trauma-informed framework emphasizes safety, trust, collaboration, empowerment, and attention to re-traumatization across organizational practices (SAMHSA, 2014).

Highly structured programs can also reward adaptations that resemble recovery. Someone whose childhood safety depended on pleasing authority may become an exemplary participant while continuing to suppress authentic feelings. Another person may learn exactly which responses staff expect, displaying apparent emotional regulation while remaining intensely vigilant about disapproval.

Group treatment illustrates a related tension. Psychoeducation and repeating skills curricula provide consistency, especially in programs with changing membership (Center for Substance Abuse Treatment, 2005). Yet someone attending treatment for the tenth time may already know the language of triggers, coping skills, cognitive distortions, and relapse prevention. The ability to explain these concepts is meaningful, but it is not equivalent to being able to live differently. Individualized reassessment remains central to appropriate treatment planning (American Society of Addiction Medicine, n.d.). A curriculum may be clinically sound yet insufficient for a particular participant if it offers information they already understand without helping them apply it under the conditions that repeatedly overwhelm their capacity. The task is not necessarily to provide more information, but to identify what prevents knowledge from becoming usable change.

Clinical progress also cannot be reduced to compliance. Symptom reduction, safer behavior, medication response, and improved functioning are genuine and important outcomes. They should not be dismissed. The question is whether they are accompanied, where appropriate, by greater autonomy, psychological flexibility, relational stability, and the ability to sustain well-being outside the treatment environment.

A similar concern arises with psychiatric diagnosis. Diagnostic categories are indispensable clinical tools, yet symptoms associated with intoxication, withdrawal, sleep disruption, medication effects, or environmental stress may resemble other psychiatric conditions. Formulations should remain open to reassessment rather than becoming fixed explanations for every subsequent difficulty. This is especially important when a diagnosis first appeared during a period of acute destabilization. Revisiting the differential diagnosis as circumstances change is not a rejection of psychiatry; it is part of careful clinical reasoning. An earlier label may remain appropriate, require refinement, or no longer adequately describe the current presentation.

FSRT asks clinicians to distinguish adaptation from reorganization. A person may become more successful at meeting treatment expectations without changing the protective strategies that originally developed under adversity. When treatment rewards these strategies without examining their cost, it may unintentionally reinforce what it seeks to resolve.

The appearance of progress is not always evidence of healing. Sometimes it reflects how successfully an individual has learned to adapt to the expectations of treatment

This is not an argument against established treatment, psychiatric care, or evidence-based interventions. It is an argument for evaluating their effects more comprehensively and for holding treatment institutions to the same standard of reflection they ask of their clients.

Beyond Survival: Reclaiming the Capacity to Live

If familiar patterns can become mistaken for health, how do we recognize that another way of living is possible?

Change may begin when an assumption becomes available for examination. Someone may recognize that what they understood as love was bound to fear of abandonment, that apparent stability required emotional suppression, or that their identity was organized around others' expectations. Such realizations can unsettle the foundations of a familiar life.

Adaptation modifies responses within existing conditions. Reorganization asks whether those conditions, and the patterns built around them, must also change. This may involve developing new boundaries, tolerating unfamiliar forms of safety, reconsidering relationships, or making decisions that disrupt longstanding expectations. Integration as reorganization describes the process through which meaningful experiences become lasting changes in how we live, relate, and respond to the world around us.

Research involving psilocybin-assisted therapy provides one developing example of how established patterns of experience may become more flexible. Early neuroimaging work identified changes in brain activity during psilocybin experiences (Carhart-Harris et al., 2012). Subsequent research in depression reported changes in communication among brain networks associated with symptom improvement (Daws et al., 2022). These findings are promising, but they do not demonstrate that an altered state automatically produces lasting psychological reorganization.

Insight alone is insufficient. A person can recognize a harmful relationship pattern and return to it, or experience temporary freedom from shame while continuing to live in conditions that evoke it. Integration requires translating awareness into choices, relationships, and practices that can be sustained beyond an extraordinary experience. For one person, that may mean practicing a boundary despite the discomfort it evokes. For another, it may involve tolerating the unfamiliar experience of being supported without having to earn that support. The significance of insight is tested not only in reflection, but in the situations that previously activated familiar patterns.

From Individual Healing to Systemic Reorganization

The same question applies to the people and institutions responsible for care. Clinicians, administrators, and organizational leaders bring their own histories, assumptions about authority, and responses to uncertainty into treatment environments. Over time, these assumptions can become policies that appear necessary simply because they are familiar.

Research has begun examining personal psychedelic experience in the training of psychedelic therapists, but its contribution to competence remains uncertain and does not justify requiring it (Villiger, 2024; Rosenbaum et al., 2024). The broader possibility is that voluntary, appropriately supported inner work, whether psychedelic-assisted where lawful and clinically suitable or undertaken through other approaches, may help professionals examine how their own adaptations shape clinical decisions.

A clinician who recognizes discomfort with vulnerability may become less likely to interpret protective behavior as resistance. An administrator who examines their relationship to control may reconsider policies organized primarily around compliance. Institutions face practical constraints, including staffing, regulation, reimbursement, and the need to maintain safety. These realities cannot be dismissed simply by calling for change. Nevertheless, constraints should be examined rather than used as automatic justification for inherited practices. But personal insight is not institutional reform. Reorganization requires accountability, collaboration, and changes to actual practices.

An FSRT perspective: Integration as Reorganization

Healing is not simply becoming better adapted to the life that made us suffer. It is developing the capacity to live differently, while recognizing that the relationships and systems shaping our lives may also need to change.

Within FSRT, integration means more than converting insight into improved behavior. It involves examining the relationships, environments, and institutions that sustain established patterns. This does not require rejecting stability, tradition, or structure. It requires asking whether preserving them still serves human well-being.

Perhaps this is the deeper challenge of The Pathology of Normal: our capacity to adapt can make harmful conditions appear ordinary, identities organized around suffering feel natural, and institutions seem effective simply because they continue to function.

Healing cannot be measured solely by how successfully people adapt to their circumstances. It must also consider whether those circumstances, and the systems maintaining them, are capable of change.

The relationship between adaptation, cultural expectations, and psychological health extends beyond any single therapeutic model. Readers are invited to consider how their experiences of belonging, endurance, and change have shaped what they understand to be normal.

A question for reflection

If we have become so skilled at adapting to the conditions that shape our suffering, how do we distinguish genuine healing from successful adaptation? And when those patterns exist within our relationships, institutions, and systems of care, are we willing to reorganize them, or will we continue asking individuals to adapt to conditions that themselves may need to change?

Therapy outcomes vary from person to person. No result is promised or guaranteed.

If this is an emergency

If you are in crisis or this is an emergency, call or text 988 (Suicide and Crisis Lifeline) or call 911.

This practice does not provide emergency or after-hours crisis services. Messages sent through this site are not monitored continuously.

About the author

Alan Romano, LCSW

Alan Romano, LCSW, is a Florida Licensed Clinical Social Worker and founder of Psycholytic Services LLC. His clinical work integrates trauma-informed psychotherapy, somatic approaches, Internal Family Systems (IFS), ketamine-assisted psychotherapy, and Functional Systems Regulation Theory (FSRT).

If you are the person this is about

If something in this article reflects what you have been experiencing, therapy can offer a place to understand the pattern with greater depth, safety, and compassion.

Psycholytic Services offers in-person therapy in Vero Beach and secure virtual therapy throughout Florida.

References

Psycholytic Perspectives

Subscribe for updates on new Psycholytic Perspectives articles

No spam, and you can unsubscribe from any email. Your address is not shared.